By: WEA RLC Principal Researcher and Writer, Elizabeth Kendal
Vietnam's Protestant and Catholic churches have long sought the return of
properties seized by the Communist authorities since they came to power. In
the north the confiscations date back to the 1950's, while in the south they
date back to 1975.
For years the church's petitions have been rejected and ignored. Occasionally
however the government will offer minimalist appeasement in the hope of
silencing Christian leaders and satisfying international observers. However,
these "gifts" are then followed by more property confiscations and
demolitions, leaving the church feeling frustrated and discouraged.
But things have changed and a new wind is blowing. Many Vietnamese are seeing
something they have never seen before. In late December 2007, thousands of
Catholics in Hanoi rallied publicly -- armed with flowers, crosses and candles
-- to pray for the return of church land and property.
On 28 March 2008 the Evangelical Church of Vietnam (South) (ECV(S)) issued a
petition not this time to the government, but to the global body of Christ
seeking prayer support in their struggle with the Communist authorities over
property, interference and discrimination. That petition: "A Call to Prayer --
To the Church of God Everywhere", can be found at Link 1.
A Spirit of prayer seems to have descended upon the Vietnamese Church giving
the believers courage, drive and a determination never before seen -- and the
government is clearly rattled.
As the Catholic prayer vigils grow and spread, Vietnam's Communist government
is working overtime to discredit the churches and their leaders and justify
its own intransigence and hostility through disinformation and slander
disseminated through the State-run media.
But despite the slander, police violence, threats of arrest, "extreme actions"
and an imminent crackdown, the protests continue day and night in all weather
and with growing numbers.
The prayer vigils are pushing the government to breaking point. But will they
result in a breakthrough in Church-State relations, or an escalation in
The situation is not looking good. The government appears to be closing the
door on dialogue, police are being deployed and the State-run media are
describing the main prayer vigil in Thai Ha as an "organisational crime"
plotted by "hostile forces" against the communist government. (Link 2)
SEEKING THE RETURN OF CONFISCATED PROPERTIES
The Evangelical Church of Vietnam (South) (ECV(S)) petitioned the government
three times during 2007 concerning discrimination, government interference in
church affairs, and the status of the 265 ECV(S) properties the Communist
authorities have seized since 1975 -- but to no avail. The government did
actually return a few small properties for appeasement sake but then in
November and December of 2007 demolished two more ECV(S) properties.
On 15 December 2007 the Catholic Archbishop of Hanoi, Joseph Ngo Quan Kiet,
requested the government restore to the church the building that served as the
Vatican ambassador's residence in Hanoi during the 1950s. The Communist
authorities requisitioned the building in 1959, and it subsequently came to be
used as a restaurant.
Sandro Magister describes what happened next: "Last December 15, the
archbishop of Hanoi, Joseph Ngo Quan Kiet, asked for the building to be given
back, and called upon the faithful to pray that justice be done.
"The faithful took him at his word. Since December 18, every evening, they
have gathered in front of the fence outside the former nunciature, praying and
carrying flowers and candles. On Christmas Eve, there were 5,000 of them.
"On December 30, Prime Minister Nguyen Tan Dung came among them. Pushing
through the crowd, he entered the archbishop's residence, where he spent
fifteen minutes meeting with Archbishop Ngo Quan Kiet. As he left, he was
"But the protest did not die out. On the contrary, it expanded to other areas
of the city.
"On January 6, the Christian feast of the Epiphany, the faithful of the parish
of Thai Ha, in Hanoi, began to demonstrate to ask for the restitution of land
and buildings confiscated by the regime [from the Redemptorist Order], and now
occupied by various government offices and a factory . . .
"On January 12, in Ho Chi Minh City, thousands of faithful took to the streets
for a vigil of solidarity with the faithful of Hanoi. The superior of the
Redemptorists, Fr Joseph Cao Dinh Tri, appealed in a message to the ruling
379/TTG, which requires the authorities to give back to their owners the goods
and lands confiscated over time, if these are no longer necessary to the
government for critical purposes. He also recalled the ordinance PL-UBTVQH11
of 2004, which states: 'The legal ownership of sites of religious interest is
protected by the law: any violation is prohibited.'
"During those same days, the faithful of the city of Ha Dong, about 25 miles
south of Hanoi, also begin demonstrating peacefully for the restitution of a
building confiscated from a parish.
"On January 24, a government delegation returned to meet the archbishop of
Hanoi. During those same hours, groups of faithful broke through into the
garden of the former nunciature, planting a cross there before they were
removed by the police . . ." (Link 3)
Sandro Magister goes on to list subsequent meetings between Catholic leaders
and government officials that eventually culminated in the 27 February
statement by the Patriot Front Official for Religious Affairs who declared
that the government can no longer ignore the legitimate request for the former
nunciature to be restored to the church.
The Catholics, however, were not appeased and the prayer vigils have continued
and spread. As Magister reports (May 2008): "Since March 17, in Ho Chi Minh
City, hundreds of sisters and faithful have met every day to pray in front of
a building taken away from the sisters of the charitable order 'Vinh Son', in
the past turned into a bordello and now about to be demolished to make room
for a hotel.
"On May 20, the protest extended to another city, Vinh Long, in the south of
the country. A four-star hotel is supposed to be built in a former orphanage
belonging to the sisters of St Paul de Chartres. The orphanage was
requisitioned in 1977, and now the bishop, the sisters, and the faithful of
the city are demanding to have it back."
Magister reports that on 15 April, the government announcement the restitution
of another Catholic property "around the basilica of Le Vang, the main Marian
Shrine in Vietnam".
However, as Magister also reported in May 2008, "These announcements have not
been followed by actions." Thus the Catholic experience mirrors that of the
Meanwhile, it was on 28 March 2008 that the Evangelical Church of Vietnam
(South) (ECV(S)) issued: "A Call to Prayer -- To the Church of God Everywhere"
concerning (amongst other things) the status of its 265 confiscated
properties. (Link 1)
But the prayer vigil by Thai Ha Redemptionist parishioners in Hanoi's Dong Da
district has recently escalated. Since mid-August, the numbers keeping vigil
at the Thai Ha Redemptorist property has escalated dramatically as Catholics
from across the country, including numerous bishops, have travelled to Hanoi
to participate in the prayer vigil in a show of solidarity, transforming the
Thai Ha vigil into something far more intensive and pivotal. The Thai Ha
property has come to be symbolic of all contentious Church-State land issues.
The government continues to respond to the prayer vigil/protests by slandering
the Catholics in the State-run media, accusing them of "criminal behaviour"
including vandalism, asserting that the Catholic Church had once signed the
property over to the State and even accusing Hanoi's Archbishop Joseph Ngo
Quang Kiet of inciting protests. (Link 4)
Father Stephen Chan Tin, who has participated in the prayer vigils, testifies
as an eye witness that they have not involved riotous or criminal behaviour.
He reports that the praise and prayer services he attended at the Thai Ha site
were "organized in a very reverent and careful manner". He laments the blatant
slander issued against the church and has issued an appeal for truth. His
paper also examines the Communist ideology that motivates such abuse of and
disrespect for humanity and private property. (Link 5)
On Thursday 28 August several Catholics were wounded as riot police attacked
the pray-ers/protesters with electric batons. Four Catholics were arrested.
Father Nguyen Van Peter Khai told AFP that police had attacked the Catholics
as they sat on the street for a peaceful vigil. "'We were in the street on
Thai Ha street and the police repressed the Christians using electric shocks,'
said Khai. 'A lot of people were beaten by police, they were beaten very
hard.' He showed AFP digital photographs showing two women bleeding from head
wounds who he said were victims of the police baton-charge."
That evening around 100 Catholics protested outside the headquarters of Dong
Da district police, calling for the release of those detained. Three more
Catholics were then arrested. (Link 6)
On Sunday 31 August a canister of tear gas was thrown in amongst some 3,000
gathered for worship at the Thai Ha site. Police were present in large
numbers, armed with cameras, taking photos of the worshippers/protesters.
On Monday 8 September, the New Hanoi and the People's Police papers published
ominous words issued by Lt-General Nguyen Van Huong, Vice-Minister of Public
Security and Major-General Nguyen Duc Nhanh, the Director of the Hanoi Police
Agency, whereby they warned Archbishop Ngo Quang Kiet of Hanoi, along with his
priests and faithful, that a crackdown was imminent.
Bishop Francis Nguyen Van Sang of Thai Binh diocese subsequently warned the
communist government "not to use the sword". "Using the sword against innocent
civilians is shameful, and will be condemned by international public opinion."
VietCatholic News Agency (VNA) reports that after the Saturday 13 September
mass at St Joseph Cathedral in Hanoi, thousands of worshippers proceeded to
the former nunciature where vigils had been held through January. Police
reinforcements were sent to prevent more Catholics from joining the
worshippers who "virtually converted the street in front of the building into
an open church for hours". (Link 8)
VNA continues: "Trembled by sudden developments at Hanoi nunciature and the
influx into the capital of ten thousands of Catholics from northern provinces,
hundreds of anti-riot police raided Cua Bac parish at 6 pm local time. A
police intelligence unit had reported a protest in the said parish. However,
it was not a protest at all. Thousands of faithful gathered at the church to
celebrate Mid-Autumn festival for children."
INTERFERENCE AND PLANTED BOGUS PRIESTS
One of the complaints of the ECV(S) mentioned in the Call to Prayer is that of
government interference in church affairs causing division and turmoil.
Catholics have likewise reported seriously destructive and unwelcome state
Further to this, AsiaNews reported on 9 September: "Some priests have appeared
on Vietnamese state TV and have been interviewed by government newspapers
speaking out against Thai Ha parishioners who want the restitution of parish
property, except that these men of the cloth are neither priests nor Catholic.
At least one of them has in fact been identified as a Communist party
official. 'They were "ordained" by the government,' was the scathing comment
from the diocese of Hanoi." (Link 9)
CRACKDOWN ON THOSE WHO TALK TO OR READ CHRISTIAN MEDIA
Frustrated by its inability to control all media, the government is now
threatening action against anyone who talks to or reads Catholic media. JB An
Dang reports for Independent Catholic News: "Police in Vietnam have begun
inspecting the computers of Catholics who have taken part in the ongoing
prayer vigils over confiscated church properties.
"A source in Hanoi said the authorities are closely monitoring overseas
reports on the protests. 'You are in serious trouble should your browsing
history include Asia-News, Catholic News Agency, Catholic World News,
Independent Catholic News, VietCatholic News, Zenit and others,' he warned.
"Plain clothed police are reported to be hunting for Catholic reporters who
are keeping the outside world, and those in Vietnam who access to the
Internet, informed about the protest.
"One journalist said: 'I was about to send an email when police swamped in.
The person next to me had his browsing history inspected. He even was forced
to log into his Gmail account for a 'security inspection'." (Link 10)
PERSECUTION, ANGER AND SLANDER MEET PERSEVERANCE, JOY AND GRACE
VietCatholic News reports: "Archbishop Joseph Ngo Quang Kiet of Hanoi and
Bishop Peter Nguyen Van De of Bui Chu joined more than two thousands of
protesters on Friday afternoon [12 September] when the superior of Thai Ha
monastery and some other priests were being 'summoned' by police. 'I know at
this time all your priests are summoned, no one stay at home. So I am here to
help them doing church keeping,' Archbishop Joseph Ngo joked with protesters.
"Bishop Peter Nguyen, who travelled more than 200 km to join with protesters,
also joked with them that state television had repeatedly warned to imprison
anyone who dared to be here to pray, especially priests. So he wanted to be
here 'out of the fear to be alone outside when all priests are jailed.'" His
joke was intensely welcomed by protesters." (Link 11)
On Sunday 14 September, the Catholics of Hanoi followed instructions issued by
the Archdioceses on Friday and prayed for God to forgive all those associated
with the State media disinformation and slander campaign, as well as those who
have issued threats against the church. (Link 11)
By Elizabeth Kendal
1) "A Call to Prayer -- To the Church of God Everywhere"
Evangelical Church of Vietnam (South) (ECV(S)) 28 March 2008http://www.worldevangelicals.org/news/view.htm?id=2068
2) Bishop of Thai Binh: Bye-bye my dear people, I will go to the jail.
11 Sept 2008 (great pictures)http://www.vietcatholic.net/News/Html/58371.htm
3) The Peaceful Revolution of Vietnam's Catholics.
By Sandro Magister 28 May 2008http://chiesa.espresso.repubblica.it/articolo/203701?eng=y
Holy row over land in Vietnam. By Nga Pham. 26 Feb 2007http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/asia-pacific/7262411.stm
4) Government sheds light on Thai Ha criminal behaviour. 30 Aug 2008http://vietnamnews.vnagency.com.vn/showarticle.php?num=03CAS300808
Hanoi Archbishop accused of inciting protests. 9 Sept 2008http://www.vietcatholic.net/News/Html/58264.htm
5) "Communism: The End Justifies the Means."
By Father Stephen Chan Tin (8 August 2008)http://www.worldevangelicals.org/news/view.htm?id=2065
6) Vietnam arrests four in Catholic land dispute, say protesters. 28 Aug 2008http://afp.google.com/article/ALeqM5hLVcCIxncCRfGBs5hAUwDl2QyTVQ
Catholics rally at Vietnam police station, three detained. 29 Aug 2008http://afp.google.com/article/ALeqM5gkF12kTbAUNUQw7IqqgurLIKYS3Q
SEE ALSO: Prayers and protests in Vietnam
By Nga Pham. BBC News, Hanoi, 2 Sep 2008http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/asia-pacific/7593251.stm
7) Vietnam: Bishop warns the government "not to use the sword" (great
pictures) http://www.vietcatholic.net/News/Html/58313.htm 10 Sep 2008
8) Thousand of Catholics protest at Hanoi former nunciature, police raid a
Hanoi parish. 13 Sept 2008 http://www.vietcatholic.net/News/Html/58478.htm
9) False priests appear on Hanoi media to discredit Catholics
By JB An Dang, AsiaNews, 9 Sep 2008http://www.asianews.it/index.php?l=en&art=13170&size=A
10) Vietnamese warned not to read ICN
By JB An Dang, 12 Sep 2008http://www.indcatholicnews.com/latdang376.html
11) Hanoi Archdiocese to observe day of prayer for state media personnel
(Great pictures) 12 Sep 2008http://www.vietcatholic.net/News/Html/58431.htm
**WEA Religious Liberty News & Analysis**
< Religious-Liberty@hub.xc.org >
Please feel free to pass this along to others giving attribution to:
"World Evangelical Alliance - Religious Liberty News & Analysis."
To subscribe for Religious Liberty News & Analysis, please send
your request to < email@example.com >
Please include your name and country or state of residence.
For more information on the World Evangelical Alliance, please see:
< http://www.WorldEvangelicalAlliance.com >,
For the Religious Liberty Commission of the WEA, see:
< http://www.WorldEvangelicalAlliance.com/commissions/rlc.htm >.
All WEA RLC material is archived at < http://www.ea.org.au/rlc >.
PRAYER: For those of you who would like more detailed information on
situations for prayer and intercession, we recommend that you
subscribe to the WEA Religious Liberty Prayer List. Each week a
different nation or situation is highlighted. To subscribe, send an
empty e-mail to < firstname.lastname@example.org > with any or no subject.
Advocates International < http://www.advocatesinternational.org >
serves as the legal and judicial advisor to the RLC. Advocates
International links many Christian lawyers and judges around the
world and has been involved in religious liberty issues for many
The Religious Liberty News & Analysis mailing list provides reports
on the state of religious liberty and persecution around the world
with those with a special interest in the field. Most members are
involved in church-based religious liberty advocacy, academic
research, missions leadership, creative-access missions, religious
media, or have prayer networks supporting these groups, although
anyone is welcome to join. Postings average one or two per
week. Information shared does not necessarily reflect the opinion
of World Evangelical Alliance, or of the WEA Religious Liberty